Understanding Commission vs Lead Fees: Which Platform Costs Less?
When you’re trying to grow your trade business, picking the right marketplace is like picking the right tool. Choose well and everything feels smooth. Choose wrong, and suddenly you’re bleeding money on fees, dead-end leads, and customers who ghost you harder than a bad Tinder date.
Here’s the real question everyone’s asking: Should you pay commission, pay-per-lead, or grab a membership? And more importantly, which one actually saves more money?
Below is a realistic guide to help you compare platforms like ServiceTasker, Hipages, Airtasker, Oneflare, and others so you can pick the right setup for your trade business.
Commission-Based Platforms — “You earn, they earn”
Commission systems take a cut from the total job invoice — usually 5% to 10%.
Where you’ll see this model:
- Some newer marketplaces
- Airtasker (different “service fee” format)
Pros
- Only pay when you complete a job
- No upfront costs; good for beginners
Cons
- Big jobs = big fees
- Fees stack up when busy
- Not ideal for high-value work
Best for
- New tradies working on small, quick jobs.
Pay-Per-Lead Platforms — “Pay for the chance, not the win”
This is the model most established platforms use — including ServiceTasker.
Lead cost depends on factors like:
- Job type
- Suburb
- Job value
- Competition
Leads typically cost $5 to $80+.
Pros
- Only pay for what you need
- Predictable, scalable spending
- Real customer details
Cons
- Some leads won’t convert
- High-value categories cost more
- Requires good follow-up
Best for
- Growing tradies who want control and scalability.
Monthly Membership Platforms — “All-access pass”
Platforms like Hipages and Oneflare offer $99–$399+ monthly packages.
Memberships usually include:
- Customer search visibility
- Lead allowances
- Profile boosts
- Direct contact access
- Discounts & perks
Pros
- Predictable monthly cost
- Steady lead flow
- Boosts branding & visibility
Cons
- You pay even without jobs
- Long-term commitment
- Not ideal for seasonal work
Best for
- Busy tradies wanting consistent visibility.
Comparing Major Aussie Platforms
ServiceTasker — Pay-Per-Lead
- No lock-in
- Flexible lead pricing
- Transparent system
Hipages — Membership + Credits
- Plans from $99/mo
- Large customer base
- Good for volume work
Airtasker — Commission
- Great for small jobs
- High price-shopping
- Best for odd jobs
Oneflare — Membership + Lead Fees
- Free + paid options
- Popular for home services
Which System Actually Costs Less?
No system is universally cheapest. It depends on:
- Your trade
- Job values
- Suburb demand
- Response speed
- Pitch quality
Go for Commission If…
You do small jobs and want zero upfront cost.
Go for Pay-Per-Lead If…
You want control and flexibility — where ServiceTasker shines.
Go for Membership If…
You want visibility and a steady stream of leads.
Final Thoughts
Your marketplace should feel like a business partner — not a bill collector.
If you want flexibility and predictable spending, ServiceTasker’s pay-per-lead model is one of the most tradie-friendly setups.
Start small, track ROI, scale up — your business, your rules.
Answers to Your Common Questions
Commission is cheapest for small jobs, pay-per-lead for controlled spending, and memberships for volume.
Commission takes a % of earnings; pay-per-lead charges upfront for customer details.
No — ServiceTasker only charges per lead.
Most are not, but some platforms credit invalid leads.
$5–$15 for basic jobs; $20–$80+ for trades.
Yes — if steady work is guaranteed.
Pay-per-lead or commission.
ServiceTasker focuses on verified leads; others vary.
Yes — most tradies use 2–3.
YOU MIGHT ALSO BE INTERESTED IN
